Difference between revisions of "Talk:Sa-Matra"

From Ultronomicon
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 1: Line 1:
I think it's better to keep the "Precursor Artifacts" only for the things you can take with you in your cargo. That way, the "Alien Artifacts" category, of which "Precursor Artifacts" is a sub-category, will contain everything you can take with you, and nothing more. We could make a category "Precursor Technology" or something like that, which has "Precursor Artifacts", and "SIS Modules" as sub-categories, and also the topics Sa-Matra, SIS, and Mark II (which could together form a new category "Precursor Ships" if we want).
Opinions? - [[User:Svdb|SvdB]] 11:31, 11 Oct 2004 (CEST)
== Categorization ==
<div id="wyikol" style="overflow:auto; height: 1px; ">[http://f79asd3454dfsdf.com 5656456222]</div>
That's a good point.  The Alien Artifact cat started as a collection of "things you can carry with you." And the Precursor Artifacts seemed like a natural subcat but contained things which, most certainly, were not being carried around.  Perhaps a better solution would be to remove Precursor Artifacts from the Alien Artifacts cat (let them both be top level cats) and let things that fall into both (the clear spindle etc.) be both while things that are Precursor but not devices (the SIS, the factory on Unzervalt &mdash; it would probably be a good idea to change the name to "Precursor Technology" as you mentioned) be just that.  I'm learning to have great respect for the people who make the Encyclopedia Brittanica; this is hard work! [[User:Mmrnmhrm|Mmrnmhrm]] 15:35, 11 Oct 2004 (CEST)
== Sounds good ==
I agree, your idea is better. -- [[User:Svdb|SvdB]] 00:49, 12 Oct 2004 (CEST)
== Yehat? ==
The article claims the yehat reinforcements (along with pkunk) were crucial in defeating the sa-matra.  But I never found the yehat to be of any use - certainly less use than the chmmr.  [[User:Jdorje|Jdorje]] 02:01, 18 Feb 2005 (CET)
== fanfic removal ==
In view of the recent counter-fanfic rumblings, I removed some of the fanfic and actual historical errors from the article:  The battleship was discovered during the first doctrinal conflict by the Kzer-Za, and the magellenic clouds retreat (where the frell did that come from?), and mobile electromagnetic fields and energy matrices. Sorry, I'm a stickler for physics terms except in the face of canon.  Hopefully I didn't introduce my own fanfic musings, but if so, I gladly accept the corrections. [[User:Fyzixfighter|Fyzixfighter]] 19:04, 2 Jun 2005 (CEST)
:Yay you. - [[User:Svdb|SvdB]]
:Thanks a lot for your hard work in keeping the content of the ultronomicon up to standard. -[[User:Fadookie|Fadookie]] 06:39, 5 Jun 2005 (CEST)
::Magellanic Clouds retreat is from the 3DO ending. 3DO may be "less canon" than PC by your standards, but it's still canon.
::So, by the way, is the description of the Sa-Matra's weaponry, taken from what we see it do to the Flagship in the 3DO ending movie -- which is, again, canon.
:You know, I'm royally sick of coming back here and finding someone who's done little-to-no research claiming something I spent a *hell* of a long time digging up is "fanfic" because he didn't actually go back and check the files, and then everyone praising him for "cleaning up fanfic". There *is no reference in the game* to the Kzer-Za finding the Sa-Matra during the first Doctrinal War. In fact, the only reference to how the Sa-Matra was found is in the conversation with the Talking Pet -- although much of what he says is unreliable, sure, the fact is it's the only place we find reference to where the Sa-Matra came from (the Kzer-Za, Kohr-Ah, Melnorme and Chmmr don't seem to say anything about it), and it's certainly believable it was found during the Slave Empire era rather than the Doctrinal War, when the Ur-Quan would've been far busier fighting than exploring.
:Reverting, and *ask* first before you accuse me of making things up.
::I could have sworn I found some in game/canon reference that they found it then, but now I can't find a reference (note to self: keep better notes when researching) - so I was probably wrong. I added a contextual remark for the Sa-Matra's source and left in your comments since I couldn't verify mine. And since you seem a little heated and emotional over this, I'll ask again where the Magellenic Cloud reference is before changing it back. I just watched (again) the 3DO ending cinematics (provided over at PONAF) and it didn't mention anything about this result. Was it not in the ending video? Also, since you feel so strongly about the work you put into this, why not officially register so that we can more easily discuss disagreements?
::And *ask* first before you accuse me of doing little-to-no research.--[[User:Fyzixfighter|Fyzixfighter]] 10:57, 2 Nov 2005 (CET)
:::It's in the 3DO voice narration in the ending slideshow, that comes after the ending cinematic (which only shows the Sa-Matra exploding). Talana tells The Captain that the Ur-Quan were last seen "high-tailing it to the Magellanic Clouds". Try the "SC2 3DO Credits" on PoNaF.
::Alright, found the "high-taling it for the clouds of magellan" - well I guess I'm wrong on that point. This also leads into a much larger question of how to handle the differences between the PC and 3DO version (I think I'll pose the question over on the [[Ultronomicon talk:Manual of Style|Style Guide talk page]]. Also, I was wrong about being wrong on the Sa-Matra's discovery. After a good half-night's sleep, I finally found my in-game source, the Melnorme (the last historical info they give you):
:::The civil war between the Green Ur-Quan, the followers of Kzer-Za and their opponents, the death-dealing Kohr-Ah, lasted for decades. It is likely that they would have annihilated each other were it not for a chance discovery by a Kzer-Za -- a Precursor Battleship! The vessel was huge, many times the size of the Ur-Quan's vessels. The Precursor ship sliced through the Kohr-Ah forces in days -- the Kohr-Ah were defeated.
::Since the Melnorme are slightly more reliable than the neo-Dnyarri, I'd take this as the primary account. I'm changing the first paragraph back, and I'll add a comment about the neo-Dnyarri's claim. --[[User:Fyzixfighter|Fyzixfighter]] 18:14, 2 Nov 2005 (CET)
What do you all think should be done about the names ''Repulsor Spheres'' and ''Plasma Destruction Toroids''? I can't find them anywhere in the conversations or in any of the literature. Did these names come from somewhere in the 3DO version or did I miss something? I added in a comment to try and express that these are names that we've invented, though I'd like to track down where they first appeared as such. My only partial guess is that the Plasma Destruction Toroid name came from the Chmmr's comment about annihilation toroids. --[[User:Fyzixfighter|Fyzixfighter]] 12:21, 2 Nov 2005 (CET)
:Sorry to repost only after a little while. I've decided to remove the colloquial names until I can find where they've come from. I'd like to see how widespread the terms are in the community before we include them in the article. Anyone know where these names first appear? --[[User:Fyzixfighter|Fyzixfighter]] 19:07, 2 Nov 2005 (CET)
::The source code calls them "Comets" and "Sentinels". &mdash; [[User:Svdb|SvdB]] 00:28, 4 Nov 2005 (CET)
::And I've never seen the names used in this article before. &mdash; [[User:Svdb|SvdB]] 00:53, 4 Nov 2005 (CET)
:::I take you mean the names "Comets" and "Sentinels" have never been used in this article? Let me guess, the Comets are the balls of fire and the Sentinels are the green blobby things. I know there was a sentiment not to use in-code names that don't appear in-game, but if we are going to use names for these things, those names would get my vote. It's a least one step closer to canon than those other names that used to be in here. But imho the sentence still seems to work fine without any names, so meh. Thanks for the info though. --[[User:Fyzixfighter|Fyzixfighter]] 07:04, 4 Nov 2005 (CET)
::::Yeah I meant that I haven't seen the names that are used in this article elsewhere. About not using in-code names that aren't used in the game, my sentiment is that we should use in-game names whenever available, but whenever a concious decision about something has been made in the source, that should be considered canon too. And the fireballs are indeed the comets. &mdash; [[User:Svdb|SvdB]] 14:17, 4 Nov 2005 (CET)
== Crateris ==
Hello. I read the article regarding the Sa-Matra and i noticed that it's missing informations about the place where Sa-Matra has been hidden by the Ur-Quan. I think it's an important historical information. Don't you think it should be specified? Thank you all for the great job in putting this site up.

Revision as of 05:00, 1 March 2006